As much as Thanksgiving and Christmas dinners are about the food, they are also about tradition. Most people are raised with certain mandatory dishes at their holiday meals, and most of the recipes are passed down through the generations so that family food traditions are preserved. As a guy who is a traditionalist in many ways, I’ve hesitated to mess with Thanksgiving meals when I’m the host, not wanting to disappoint people expecting the standards. But in recent years, we’ve been having two Thanksgiving meals per year (split amongst various family members) and even had a holiday party or two. These have given me an opportunity to experiment a bit. We’ve previously blogged about my semi-n0n-traditional smoked turkey, bourbon mashed sweet potatoes, port wine cranberry sauce, and whiskey glazed carrots, but now I want to talk about stuffing. Or dressing. Or whatever you call it.
My mom did the standard Pepperidge Farm stuffing, or something close to it, with sauteed celery and onions and chicken broth mixed in together and some stuffed in the turkey, and some baked on the side in a casserole dish to get a nice crust on it. I always liked the crusty one more than the mushy one that came out of the turkey, but to each his own. I actually liked this stuffing a lot, especially with a nice layer of gravy spooned across the top of it.
A few years ago, my friend Kat suggested I try a sourdough, parmesan, and artichoke stuffing that her mom makes that she swore up and down was the greatest stuffing she’d ever had. Sounded really good, but also sounded like the kind of thing that could get you banned from hosting Thanksgiving if you dropped it on unsuspecting family members who were expecting their stuffing to be old school (especially my dad who hates mushrooms…)! So we tried it out on our friends at our holiday party last year, and it was outstanding. It might still be a little avant garde to be the only stuffing available for a traditional family Thanksgiving, but if you’re like me and likes to do turkeys throughout the year or if you have adventurous friends coming over for a holiday party, I highly recommend you try it.
- 1 lb sliced mushrooms
- 1 tbsp butter
- 2 yellow or sweet onions (about ¾ pound), chopped
- 1 cup celery, chopped
- 2 tbsp garlic, minced
- 2 cups reduced sodium chicken broth + some in reserve
- 1 lb loaf sourdough bread, cut into ½ inch cubes
- 2 6-oz jars marinated artichoke hearts, drained and chopped
- 1 cup grated parmesan cheese
- 1½ tsp poultry seasoning
- 1½ tbsp minced fresh rosemary leaves, or ¾ tsp dried rosemary
- 1 egg
- salt and pepper
- VERY LARGE BOWL!
- Saute mushrooms, butter, onions, celery and garlic, until onions are opaque.
- Transfer veggies to large bowl.
- Add a bit of broth to pan and scrape up residue from the vegetables, and add to bowl.
- Add remaining broth into bowl and add bread, artichoke hearts, parmesan cheese, poultry seasoning and rosemary. Mix well.
- Add salt and pepper to taste (I added about ½ tsp of each)
- Beat egg in a small bowl and add to stuffing. Mix in. (The original recipe suggests creating a well in the stuffing, breaking the egg into it, and then beating it there, and mixing it into the stuffing. I think my way is easier).
- Put stuffing into a lightly greased 9 x 13 casserole dish and place in a 350 degree oven. For moist stuffing, cover with foil, for crustier stuffing, leave uncovered
- Bake until lightly browned or heated through–about 45 minutes to an hour.
You could switch chicken broth for veggie broth, if you wanted a vegetarian option, and skip the egg if you wanted a vegan option, I guess…
Yields 10 cups to serve 12. This works out to 8/10 of a cup per serving. It's easier to just divide your baking pan into 12 equal servings (3 down, 4 across).
Yes! Thanks for the shout out! It was actually created by a woman in Sutter Creek. This is my favorite stuffing ever and I actually whine and cry if it is not on the table. My mom attempted to change the stuffing one year. I threatened not to come to the next family function if she even tried to change it ;p
oh my! bread not toasted? Big mistake! I spied this recipe in Sunset Mag 10 years ago in attempt to find my own tradition. My Floridian momma made the best cornbread sausage stuffing, but I was not up to the task. Yup, that woman in Sutter Creek CA!